Stuck at Cape York

[RY-Journeyman]

Turbo engines and diesels especially will break catastrophically with water added and it does not take much, about half a cup full for a BMW X5. (My Grenadier was anticipated to have 2 bent con-rods, but the turbos were consider scrap).

A low revving petrol engine with a lower compression ratio is more likely to survive, (and much easier to fix).

Is non turbo diesel better than non turbo petrol? Not sure but history would suggest that as both the Willys and Land Rover series 1 were petrol and survived the Second World War that petrol is king in the most challenging of circumstances. Good call.

 

[landmannnn]

Turbo engines and diesels especially will break catastrophically with water added and it does not take much, about half a cup full for a BMW X5. (My Grenadier was anticipated to have 2 bent con-rods, but the turbos were consider scrap).

A low revving petrol engine with a lower compression ratio is more likely to survive, (and much easier to fix).

I've repaired a couple of older land-rover engines with water ingress, one just flattened a big end bearing, the other bent a conrod as well. So both fixed in a few hours for a few pounds.

WW2 jeeps would be even easier being sidevalve (flathead)

Not that those engines were comparable to modern engines.

 

[Jeremy996]

Is non turbo diesel better than non turbo petrol? Not sure but history would suggest that as both the Willys and Land Rover series 1 were petrol and survived the Second World War that petrol is king in the most challenging of circumstances. Good call.

As a diesel engine has a much higher compression ratio, the damage to the con-rods or piston is more likely to be catastrophic/serious. Conversly, diesel engines are usually more robustly made.

Fishing drowned LR109 Series IIIs from deep water as a TA soldier in the early '80s, we did not have to do much more than take the plugs out, expel the water and change the oil, unless someone had driven in at full noise and fury!

 

[Tazzieman]

B57 Cr 16:1 ; B58 = 11:1

 

[Shopkeep]

B57 Cr 16:1 ; B58 = 11:1

Willys Go Devil L134 7:1

 

[Tazzieman]

Willys Go Devil L134 7:1

Same as early Land Rovers. The tractor that takes you to the pigsty and pub.

 

[Shopkeep]

Same as early Land Rovers. The tractor that takes you to the pigsty and pub.

And no steering pump noise to bitch about. Very effective HVAC, as long as you want the same temp as outside.

 

[Blackwolf]

Is non turbo diesel better than non turbo petrol? Not sure but history would suggest that as both the Willys and Land Rover series 1 were petrol and survived the Second World War that petrol is king in the most challenging of circumstances. Good call.

I've yet to meet a SI Land-Rover that survived WW2 (I know one appears in the film 633 Squadron but that's an anachronism)!

 

[Happyoldgit]

I've yet to meet a SI Land-Rover that survived WW2 (I know one appears in the film 633 Squadron but that's an anachronism)!

Don't forget the Series that appeared at the end of Ice Cold In Alex...