The Grenadier Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to contribute to the community by adding your own topics, posts, and connect with other members through your own private inbox! INEOS Agents, Dealers or Commercial vendors please use the contact us link at the bottom of the page.

Letter to Lynne Calder

Well, @Tom D , if it helps at all in your conversation with Lynne, here's the perspective of someone who's not a Grenadier owner, but is a solid candidate for a Grenadier buyer. Not to be overly solipsistic, but I feel I'm probably of the general demographic and mindset of the person out there who has not bought one yet, but could very well do so if the conditions were right.

And as such, I really don't see a world in which there's someone who's interested in an Ineos who does not read about them online first. Maybe not all of them do deep research, but do at least enough research to know what they could be getting into. Can't imagine a buyer that just casually strolled into the dealership and drives one off the lot without knowing about them first. I'm also of the demographic who's always relied on vehicle-specific forums, so here i am.

I should note that I do not live close to any Ineos dealership. I'm in Kansas City, and the closest dealer is around 8 hours away. Would not really scare me too much for day-to-day stuff. I can spin a wrench; I owned a Land Rover for 9 years, 6 of which were out of warranty, during which I mostly took care of it myself. Service stuff, basic mechanic stuff. Anything that could be done in a day or less, I'd do.

That all in mind, what people can read online is definitely concerning. Some things, like the front drive shaft, would be a bitter pill but also sort of par for the course on a unique, brand new vehicle from a brand new manufacturer. Replacing a drive shaft with a better aftermarket one is a one-banana job. Not what you want to need to do on a new vehicle, but it is what it is. It's not like I don't spend money on parts to modify a brand new vehicle anyway.

But the lack of a service manual and OBD reader is just too big a barrier. As has been mentioned, that in and of itself violates the laws of at least 5 states, and I'm sure some various tort or contract claims could be brought in many others.

Part and parcel with that issue is the limited dealer/service network. If there's some fix that requires more than what I'd care to do (or more than I'd care to spend out of pocket), 8 hours to get to a dealer service location is just too much. This one probably seems obvious, but hear me out. If Ineos wants to be selective and roll out its dealerships slow and methodically, whatever. Maybe Ineos is having growing pains, or maybe it wants to "protect" the existing dealers and not water down these dealers' sales on a vehicle that's probably always been destined to be a low volume proposition from the get go.

But Ineos should really should partner up with some sort of service network to get more places that can do warranty work. I understand that would make it pretty unique (in the U.S., at least), as I'm not aware of any other manufacturer who allows warranty work to be done outside the manufacturer's dealer network. Nonetheless, if Ineos wants to generate sales, at this point it needs to think outside the box. This HAS to be the main thing holding back sales at this point. I have no problem flying to Chicago, Dallas, or Colorado Springs to buy one, so long as I know I can get it worked on closer to home. They do this, and I guarantee sales would significantly bounce up and the existing dealer network would be much happier.

(I suppose this could open Pandora's box--if existing service locations can't get parts in timely fashion, bumping sales with more service networks won't help. But let's table that for now.)

Despite all this, I still can't get the idea of owning one of these out of my head. I feel like I'm a drawn bow just ready to shoot that arrow, and all it would take is Ineos getting its shit together on even just a basic level for that to happen.
 
Last edited:
Well, @Tom D , if it helps at all in your conversation with Lynne, here's the perspective of someone who's not a Grenadier owner, but is a solid candidate for a Grenadier buyer. Not to be overly solipsistic, but I feel I'm probably of the general demographic and mindset of the person out there who has not bought one yet, but could very well do so if the conditions were right.

And as such, I really don't see a world in which there's someone who's interested in an Ineos who does not read about them online first. Maybe not all of them do deep research, but do at least enough research to know what they could be getting into. Can't imagine a buyer that just casually strolled into the dealership and drives one off the lot without knowing about them first. I'm also of the demographic who's always relied on vehicle-specific forums, so here i am.

I should note that I do not live close to any Ineos dealership. I'm in Kansas City, and the closest dealer is around 8 hours away. Would not really scare me too much for day-to-day stuff. I can spin a wrench; I owned a Land Rover for 9 years, 6 of which were out of warranty, during which I mostly took care of it myself. Service stuff, basic mechanic stuff. Anything that could be done in a day or less, I'd do.

That all in mind, what people can read online is definitely concerning. Some things, like the front drive shaft, would be a bitter pill but also sort of par for the course on a unique, brand new vehicle from a brand new manufacturer. Replacing a drive shaft with a better aftermarket one is a one-banana job. Not what you want to need to do on a new vehicle, but it is what it is. It's not like I don't spend money on parts to modify a brand new vehicle anyway.

But the lack of a service manual and OBD reader is just too big a barrier. As has been mentioned, that in and of itself violates the laws of at least 5 states, and I'm sure some various tort or contract claims could be brought in many others.

Part and parcel with that issue is the limited dealer/service network. If there's some fix that requires more than what I'd care to do (or more than I'd care to spend out of pocket), 8 hours to get to a dealer service location is just too much. This one probably seems obvious, but hear me out. If Ineos wants to be selective and roll out its dealerships slow and methodically, whatever. Maybe Ineos is having growing pains, or maybe it wants to "protect" the existing dealers and not water down these dealers' sales on a vehicle that's probably always been destined to be a low volume proposition from the get go.

But Ineos should really should partner up with some sort of service network to get more places that can do warranty work. I understand that would make it pretty unique (in the U.S., at least), as I'm not aware of any other manufacturer who allows warranty work to be done outside the manufacturer's dealer network. Nonetheless, if Ineos wants to generate sales, at this point it needs to think outside the box. This HAS to be the main thing holding back sales at this point. I have no problem flying to Chicago, Dallas, or Colorado Springs to buy one, so long as I know I can get it worked on closer to home. They do this, and I guarantee sales would significantly bounce up and the existing dealer network would be much happier.

(I suppose this could open Pandora's box--if existing service locations can't get parts in timely fashion, bumping sales with more service networks won't help. But let's table that for now.)

Despite all this, I still can't get the idea of owning one of these out of my head. I feel like I'm a drawn bow just ready to shoot that arrow, and all it would take is Ineos getting its shit together on even just a basic level for that to happen.
I had to look up “solipsistic.” It means “very self-centered, or extreme egocentricity.” Thanks @ryanjl for expanding my vocabulary this morning!
 
It is a big problem, especially here in the UK. I was an early adopter and relied on the brochure at the time:
1751973207973.png

We are a very long way away from this "promise"!!
 
I don’t how far away we are from it.

Owners might get access to the service manual tomorrow.

The OBDII might be a month or 6 months or 2 years. Hopefully not the latter.
 
It is a big problem, especially here in the UK. I was an early adopter and relied on the brochure at the time:
View attachment 7901364
We are a very long way away from this "promise"!!
Maybe whoever wrote this was using it as an application to be the speech writer for our PM
 
They must have got the job!

In response to the Barons' comments, the brochure I cut and pasted this excerpt from was published in 2022, so we are already 3 years away from fulfilment of the promises, even if tomorrow happens, and some, like Bosch service centres (and that was not expressed to be only an ambition, but a commitment), seem to have evaporated altogether. I love the vehicle, but as more and more options for servicing diminish, purchase prices are pushed up with consequential sales volumes falling, and the end of ICE in the UK on the horizon, not to mention moving the vehicle away from being a work vehicle to a leisure vehicle (for which I am sorry to say there are better/more sensible options for the money), all make me question its long term viability, and the level of investment Ineos are likely to continue to make in its development - in the UK - appreciate ROW may be different. Hope I haven't got a modern day DeLorean!
 
They must have got the job!

In response to the Barons' comments, the brochure I cut and pasted this excerpt from was published in 2022, so we are already 3 years away from fulfilment of the promises, even if tomorrow happens, and some, like Bosch service centres (and that was not expressed to be only an ambition, but a commitment), seem to have evaporated altogether. I love the vehicle, but as more and more options for servicing diminish, purchase prices are pushed up with consequential sales volumes falling, and the end of ICE in the UK on the horizon, not to mention moving the vehicle away from being a work vehicle to a leisure vehicle (for which I am sorry to say there are better/more sensible options for the money), all make me question its long term viability, and the level of investment Ineos are likely to continue to make in its development - in the UK - appreciate ROW may be different. Hope I haven't got a modern day DeLorean!
I agree that in the UK sales will always be limited, and so therefore will be the number of dealers.
On the plus side, as soon as the scan tool arrives lack of dealers will be much less of an issue. I'm not a huge fan of my dealer anyway.. Service parts can be had from the likes of Dingbro and Euro car parts.. The only issue that they need to solve is bespoke parts availability which they are working on. My faulty turbo hose arrived pretty quickly so maybe things are improving...
 
I agree that in the UK sales will always be limited, and so therefore will be the number of dealers.
On the plus side, as soon as the scan tool arrives lack of dealers will be much less of an issue. I'm not a huge fan of my dealer anyway.. Service parts can be had from the likes of Dingbro and Euro car parts.. The only issue that they need to solve is bespoke parts availability which they are working on. My faulty turbo hose arrived pretty quickly so maybe things are improving...

Yep I got an alternator in under 48 hours.

Anything I’ve ordered has arrived in under a week. It’s not bad, honestly.
 
Long story. My Ineos was in a bodyshop for 3 months, as you know, after a minor tap with an old defender in the snow.

Anyway, bodyshop neither kept it on a trickle charger, disconnected the batteries nor put it in transport mode. The main battery died, insurance eventually agreed to replace it which my local dealer did but the problem still wasn’t sorted - battery discharging at an astonishing 50-110A, tech tried a few things after speaking to Ineos directly and they came to the conclusion the dying battery knackered the alternator. Replaced under warranty which actually was a surprise and pretty good service - in my head that’s down to the Bodyshop / Insurance but, either way, it’s fixed now.
 
Last edited:
Would really like to understand this technically. Also, how this could kill an alternator.
Don't google it or you will come away with two confident yet diametricallty opposed answers.
To summarise , and to quote Christian from LR Time channel , ''red is black and plus is minus''
:)
 
Would really like to understand this technically. Also, how this could kill an alternator.

Yeah me too. Ineos tech guy didn’t understand it, nothing is pulling 110A obviously, he put it down to a software glitch.

What happened was the main battery was left unattended for 3 months and went completely flat then would not hold a charge and it is suspected that the alternator has failed, perhaps from being over worked trying to charge a dying battery? I’m not sure, as you can tell I am no expert in automotive electrics.

Anyway, moral of the story, don’t let anyone leave your Grenadier for 3 months without it being on a trickle charger.
 
Last edited:
ChatGPT says:

An alternator is designed to maintain a charged battery, not recharge a deeply discharged one. If the battery is significantly depleted, the alternator has to work much harder to bring it back up to charge, and this can lead to:
1. Overheating – The alternator generates more current than normal, producing excess heat, which can damage internal components like the diodes and voltage regulator.
2. Premature wear – The added strain can shorten the lifespan of the alternator bearings and other moving parts.
3. Voltage spikes – If the voltage regulator is stressed, it may cause unstable charging, potentially damaging electrical components.
 
ChatGPT says:

An alternator is designed to maintain a charged battery, not recharge a deeply discharged one. If the battery is significantly depleted, the alternator has to work much harder to bring it back up to charge, and this can lead to:
1. Overheating – The alternator generates more current than normal, producing excess heat, which can damage internal components like the diodes and voltage regulator.
2. Premature wear – The added strain can shorten the lifespan of the alternator bearings and other moving parts.
3. Voltage spikes – If the voltage regulator is stressed, it may cause unstable charging, potentially damaging electrical components.
and yet, that still should not happen.
 
Back
Top Bottom